One of the more puzzling experiences in college admissions today is when a student is admitted to a highly selective university but rejected by another college where their grades and test scores put them comfortably above the average. Parents often explain this by pointing to a practice known as “yield protection.” The assumption is that the second college recognized that the student was unlikely to enroll and decided not to offer them a spot.
There is some institutional logic to this. Colleges have an interest in accurately predicting how many admitted students will enroll. An unexpectedly large freshman class can create housing shortages and overcrowded classes; an unexpectedly small one can have significant financial consequences. But it is difficult to know whether these considerations influenced any individual admissions decision.
What I find more revealing about these situations is how the college ended up on the student’s list in the first place. Families tend to classify colleges as reaches, targets and likely schools, largely on the basis of academic credentials and acceptance rates. These categories are intended to describe the probability of admission, but somewhere along the way, they become a hierarchy of desirability.
You can see this in how families allocate their time. They’ll spend an entire weekend visiting a reach school, researching its academic programs and arranging lunch with a current student. Meanwhile, a college where admission is more likely might get a drive through campus on the way home. Students can spend months preparing to attend colleges they have relatively little chance of getting into without developing much of an understanding of the places where they are more likely to spend four years.
Some colleges take demonstrated interest into account when evaluating applicants. Others, including Columbia, explicitly state that campus visits, information sessions and correspondence with admissions officers do not factor into their decisions.
But the emphasis on demonstrated interest has also changed the purpose of these interactions. Parents ask whether attending a virtual information session will help their child’s chances of admission. Far less frequently do they ask whether their child learned anything from attending it.
With the holidays approaching, many families will incorporate college visits into their travel plans. I’d encourage them to spend some of that time exploring the less selective colleges on their child’s list. Find out who teaches introductory courses, how accessible research opportunities are and what students do on weekends. These are things that can be difficult to discern from an acceptance rate or a college ranking.
I’ve always thought that one measure of a well-constructed college list is whether a student could get excited about attending its least selective institution. That requires students to develop preferences independent of how difficult a college is to get into.
And for some families, that proves to be one of the harder parts of the college admissions process.

Marc is the author of Untangling the Ivy League, a best-selling guidebook on the Ancient Eight. He earned a BA from Cornell University and an MBA from University of North Carolina – Chapel Hill. Marc chaired the admissions ambassadors at Cornell and the admissions advisory board at UNC.